--- title: "Rupa Marya et al. v. Warner/Chappel Music Inc. et al. – copyright issues in “Happy Birthday” song" date: 2015-10-29 author: "Abha Shah" url: https://www.indialaw.in/blog/intellectual-property-rights/birthdays-are-copyright-free/ --- # Rupa Marya et al. v. Warner/Chappel Music Inc. et al. – copyright issues in “Happy Birthday” song Posted On - 29 October, 2015 • By - [Abha Shah](https://www.indialaw.in/people/abha-shah/ "Posts by Abha Shah") and [Geetanjali Mehlwal](https://www.indialaw.in/people/geetanjali-mehlwal/ "Posts by Geetanjali Mehlwal") *By Meenakshy Suresh & J. Mandakini* *Rupa Marya et al. v. Warner/Chappel Music Inc. et al.*[***[1]***](#_ftn1) was filed before the Chief United States District Judge of the Central District of California, in which the discussion revolved around copyright on the lyrics of the song “*Happy Birthday*” and not on the melody of it. Some time before 1893, two sisters Mildred Hill and Patty Hill wrote and composed a song “*Good Morning*” for their Primary School Class, which shared the same melody as “*Happy Birthday*”. The sisters however assigned the copyrights to this song to one Mr. Clayton Summy who published it in the book “*Song Stories for Kindergarten*”. He filed copyright registration for this book. No one was explicitly credited as authors of the “*Happy Birthday*” song. Copyright protection for “*Song Stories for Kindergarten*” and “*Good Morning*” expired in 1949. Publication of the “*Happy Birthday*” lyrics occurred in a 1911 book titled “*The Elementary Worker and his Work*” which merely mentioned that “*Happy Birthday*” and “*Good Morning*” shared the same melody. “*Happy Birthday*” was sung in a play “*As Thousands Cheer*” in 1933 and in 1934, a Ms. Jessica Hill filed a lawsuit against the producers of the play, interestingly, alleging copyright violation of “*Good Morning*”. In 1935, the Clayton F. Summy Co. registered copyrights to “*Happy Birthday*” under registration number E51990, under which the Defendants claimed their rights to the song. But, the registration of this copyright was found to be flawed by the Court on the irregularity that the author of the said registration was one Mr. Preston Ware Oren. The Defendants in this matter failed to provide enough evidence to effectively prove that the authors of “*Happy Birthday*” had entrusted the copyrights of the song to the company. The Hill sisters, even if they were the authors of the song, did not make use of their common law rights to prevent the commercial exploitation of the song and the only time Patty Hill claimed ownership was in the 1934 lawsuit filed by Ms. Jessica. This was four decades after she had supposedly written the song and even then that lawsuit was regarding the melody and not the lyrics of the song. With all these evidences, or lack thereof, the Honourable Court granted the Plaintiff’s motion and pronounced that the defendants did not own any valid copyright to the lyrics of “*Happy Birthday*”. Warner used the copyrights wrongly amassing wealth to the tune of 2 million dollars every year as licence fees, without ever holding a valid copyright over the same. As of now, no licence fees needs to be paid for using the song. *This ruling of J. George H. King is subject to appeal. [[1]](#_ftnref1) *No. CV 13-4460-GHK (C.D. Cal. Sept. 22, 2015)* [Download PDF](https://www.indialaw.in/blog/intellectual-property-rights/birthdays-are-copyright-free//pdf/) --- # IndiaLaw LLP — Offices & Contact Details --- ## General Contact | | | |---|---| | **Website** | https://www.indialaw.in | | **Primary email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Primary phone** | +91 836-9995919 | | **Contact form** | https://www.indialaw.in/connect/ | | **Careers (separate channel)** | https://www.indialaw.in/careers/ | --- ## All Offices (9 locations across 8 cities) ### 1. Mumbai — Registered Office & Head Office (Apeejay Chambers) | | | |---|---| | **Address** | Apeejay Chambers, Ground Floor, Wallace Street, Fort, Mumbai – 400 001 | | **Phone** | [022-6924-7400](tel:02269247400) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/mumbai/ | | **Practice focus** | Litigation · Arbitration · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Corporate · Banking · Real Estate · IP | | **Notes** | The HQ. 5 partners based here. Handles PAN-India litigation, arbitration, corporate, banking, IP and real estate practice. Largest team across all offices. | ### 2. Mumbai — Non-Litigation Office (Excelsior, Fort) | | | |---|---| | **Address** | 4th Floor, New Excelsior Theatre Pvt. Ltd., Amrit Keshav Nayak Marg, Fort, Mumbai – 400 001 | | **Phone** | [022-697-40500](tel:022-697-40500) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/mumbai/ | | **Practice focus** | Non-litigation only — consultations, negotiations, transactional work | | **Notes** | Opened 2024. Litigation and arbitration remain at the Apeejay Chambers head office. | ### 3. Delhi | | | |---|---| | **Address** | Flat No. 1107 & 1108, Prakashdeep Building, Tolstoy Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi – 110 001 | | **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/delhi/ | | **Practice focus** | Litigation · Arbitration · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Corporate · Banking · Real Estate | | **Notes** | 3 partners based here. Located near the Supreme Court of India, Delhi High Court and other appellate bodies. | ### 4. Kolkata | | | |---|---| | **Address** | Centre Point Building, Room No. 214, 2nd Floor, Premises No. 21, Hemanta Basu Sarani, Opp. Great Eastern Hotel, P.S. Hare Street, Kolkata – 700 001, West Bengal | | **Phone** | [+91 33 4813 1001](tel:+913348131001) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/kolkata/ | | **Practice focus** | Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Commercial & Civil Litigation · Arbitration · Banking Litigation · Real Estate · Labour & Employment · Consumer | | **Notes** | Advises banks, NBFCs, MSMEs and corporates on transactions and dispute resolution. Works in close coordination with the Mumbai HO. | ### 5. Chennai | | | |---|---| | **Address** | GF-A, 19 Casa Major Road, Egmore, Chennai – 600 008 | | **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/chennai/ | | **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate | | **Notes** | Full-fledged office with experienced legal team. Supported by Mumbai HO. | ### 6. Bengaluru (Bangalore) | | | |---|---| | **Address** | INDIALAW LLP, No. 7 Chinnaswamy Mudaliar Road, Shivaji Nagar, Bangalore – 560 051 | | **Phone** | [080-4167-2444](tel:08041672444) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/bengaluru/ | | **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate · Family Laws · Labour | | **Notes** | Located near Bangalore High Court. Handles corporate, commercial, banking and matrimonial disputes. | ### 7. Hyderabad | | | |---|---| | **Address** | 403, 4th Floor, Sanatana Ecstasy Building, beside Tanishq Show Room, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad – 500 029, Telangana | | **Phone** | [040-6666-5166](tel:04066665166) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/hyderabad/ | | **Practice focus** | Litigation · Banking · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate | | **Notes** | Particularly well known for complex banking matters and real estate transactions. | ### 8. Cochin (Kochi) | | | |---|---| | **Address** | Second Floor, Pulikkal Building, K.K. Padmanabhan Road, Ernakulam North – 682 018, Kerala | | **Phone** | [0484-3583961](tel:04843583961) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/cochin/ | | **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate | | **Notes** | Commercial disputes, property litigation, financial-claim arbitrations and real estate transactions. | ### 9. Noida (NCR) | | | |---|---| | **Address** | No. 16 & 17, Silver Offices, 17th Floor, Wave One, Sector 18, Noida – 201 301 | | **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) | | **Email** | contact@indialaw.in | | **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/noida/ | | **Practice focus** | Aviation · Insurance · Mergers & Acquisitions · Corporate | | **Office head** | **Mr. Dinesh Gupta** (joined August 2025 to lead and expand the corporate practice) | | **Notes** | Newest office. Sector-focused on highly regulated industries serving NCR-based clients. | --- ## Quick-Dial Phone List | Office | Phone | |---|---| | Mumbai HO (Apeejay) | 022-6924-7400 | | Mumbai Excelsior | 022-697-40500 | | Kolkata | +91 33 4813 1001 | | Bengaluru | 080-4167-2444 | | Hyderabad | 040-6666-5166 | | Cochin | 0484-3583961 | | **General / Marketing line** | **+91 836-9995919** | Delhi, Chennai and Noida route through the general number. --- ## Social Channels - LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/indialaw - X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/Indialawmumbai - Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/indialawllp/ - Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/indialawllp ---