---
title: "Jet Airways Ratio Re-affirmed: Liquidator Need Not Honour Post-liquidation PF Penalties"
date: 2025-07-23
author: "Shrishail Kittad"
url: https://www.indialaw.in/blog/insolvency-bankruptcy/jet-airways-ratio-re-affirmed-liquidator-need-not-honour-post-liquidation-pf-penalties/
---

# Jet Airways Ratio Re-affirmed: Liquidator Need Not Honour Post-liquidation PF Penalties

Posted On - 23 July, 2025 •

By - [Shrishail Kittad](https://www.indialaw.in/people/adv-shrishail-kittad/ "Posts by Shrishail Kittad") and [Rahul Sundaram](https://www.indialaw.in/people/rahul-sundaram/ "Posts by Rahul Sundaram")

[![Jet Airways Ratio Re-affirmed](https://www.indialaw.in/wp-content/uploads/72c9c2e3-55a8-4116-8d17-dd442567c279.jpg)](https://www.indialaw.in/wp-content/uploads/72c9c2e3-55a8-4116-8d17-dd442567c279.jpg)

On 9 July 2025 the National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench, closed a long-running skirmish between the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation and the liquidator of Raihan Healthcare Private Limited.  The dispute began in March 2019 when the Chennai Bench admitted the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) against the Kerala-based hospital chain.  A year later the same bench ordered its liquidation; Chartered Accountant Mahalingam Suresh Kumar was appointed liquidator on 7 February 2020. 

The EPFO, which had been chasing unpaid PF dues since 2016, filed its first consolidated claim of ₹1.73 crore in December 2019 and repeated it in Form G on 6 March 2020—well within the final cut-off date of 11 March 2020.  The liquidator admitted this entire amount and has already paid ₹1.90 crore, treating the basic employer and employee contributions as exempt from the liquidation estate under Section 36(4)(a)(iii) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. 

Trouble arose in 2023.  After fresh inspections and Section 7A assessments that culminated between February and April 2023, the EPFO submitted a revised claim of ₹4.72 crore.  The new figure added ₹40.99 lakh for March-December 2019 dues, ₹1.81 crore in damages under Section 14B, and ₹1.06 crore in interest under Section 7Q.  The liquidator refused to recognise the additional demand; he merely asked the EPFO to approach the Tribunal for modification of the stakeholder list.  EPFO responded by filing an application on 25 January 2024 under Section 60(5) of the Code, praying that the balance ₹2.82 crore be declared exempt from the liquidation estate and be paid on priority. 

The EPFO’s counsel argued that PF contributions are held in trust for workers and therefore never form part of the debtor’s assets.  They relied on a line of NCLAT and Supreme Court judgments—Jet Airways, Assam Tea Employees Provident Fund, Rainbow Papers and others—that have consistently placed such contributions outside the waterfall mechanism.  They also insisted that the liquidator had not formally rejected the revised claim and therefore the Tribunal’s intervention was appropriate under Section 60(5).  

The liquidator countered that all the impugned assessments were completed after liquidation had commenced in December 2019.  Once the moratorium under Section 33(5) kicked in, no quasi-judicial proceeding—including a fresh Section 7A inquiry—could validly create fresh liabilities.  The liquidator also pointed out that damages and interest are penal in nature and rank as unsecured operational debt, entitled only to a Section 53 waterfall share.  Finally, he maintained that the revised claim was filed three years late without any prayer for condonation of delay and ought to be dismissed on that ground alone. 

After reviewing the pleadings and the recent NCLAT decisions in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Girish Siriram Juneja (30 June 2025) and the Assistance Provident Fund Commissioner v. Chandra Prakash Jain (2024), the two-member Bench of Madhu Sinha (Technical) and Vinay Goel (Judicial) agreed with the liquidator.  It held that any assessment conducted after the liquidation order is void because it violates the statutory moratorium embedded in Sections 14 and 33(5) of the Code.  While the basic contributions already admitted remain protected, penal damages and interest that crystallised only through post-liquidation orders cannot be fast-tracked or exempted. 

The Tribunal therefore dismissed the application, confirming that the EPFO must be content with the ₹1.90 crore already disbursed and that no further amount is payable from the estate.  The order has been circulated electronically and the file consigned to records, putting an end to a litigation that tested the outer limits of statutory moratorium and the sanctity of liquidation timelines.

For further details write to [contact@indialaw.in](mailto:contact@indialaw.in)

Disclaimer - This article is intended for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should seek specific legal counsel in relation to their individual circumstances.

[Download PDF](https://www.indialaw.in/blog/insolvency-bankruptcy/jet-airways-ratio-re-affirmed-liquidator-need-not-honour-post-liquidation-pf-penalties//pdf/)

[Insolvency & Bankruptcy](https://www.indialaw.in/expertise/insolvency-and-bankruptcy-laws/)

---

# IndiaLaw LLP — Offices & Contact Details

---

## General Contact

| | |
|---|---|
| **Website** | https://www.indialaw.in |
| **Primary email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Primary phone** | +91 836-9995919 |
| **Contact form** | https://www.indialaw.in/connect/ |
| **Careers (separate channel)** | https://www.indialaw.in/careers/ |


---

## All Offices (9 locations across 8 cities)

### 1. Mumbai — Registered Office & Head Office (Apeejay Chambers)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | Apeejay Chambers, Ground Floor, Wallace Street, Fort, Mumbai – 400 001 |
| **Phone** | [022-6924-7400](tel:02269247400) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/mumbai/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Arbitration · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Corporate · Banking · Real Estate · IP |
| **Notes** | The HQ. 5 partners based here. Handles PAN-India litigation, arbitration, corporate, banking, IP and real estate practice. Largest team across all offices. |

### 2. Mumbai — Non-Litigation Office (Excelsior, Fort)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | 4th Floor, New Excelsior Theatre Pvt. Ltd., Amrit Keshav Nayak Marg, Fort, Mumbai – 400 001 |
| **Phone** | [022-697-40500](tel:022-697-40500) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/mumbai/ |
| **Practice focus** | Non-litigation only — consultations, negotiations, transactional work |
| **Notes** | Opened 2024. Litigation and arbitration remain at the Apeejay Chambers head office. |

### 3. Delhi

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | Flat No. 1107 & 1108, Prakashdeep Building, Tolstoy Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi – 110 001 |
| **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/delhi/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Arbitration · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Corporate · Banking · Real Estate |
| **Notes** | 3 partners based here. Located near the Supreme Court of India, Delhi High Court and other appellate bodies. |

### 4. Kolkata

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | Centre Point Building, Room No. 214, 2nd Floor, Premises No. 21, Hemanta Basu Sarani, Opp. Great Eastern Hotel, P.S. Hare Street, Kolkata – 700 001, West Bengal |
| **Phone** | [+91 33 4813 1001](tel:+913348131001) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/kolkata/ |
| **Practice focus** | Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Commercial & Civil Litigation · Arbitration · Banking Litigation · Real Estate · Labour & Employment · Consumer |
| **Notes** | Advises banks, NBFCs, MSMEs and corporates on transactions and dispute resolution. Works in close coordination with the Mumbai HO. |

### 5. Chennai

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | GF-A, 19 Casa Major Road, Egmore, Chennai – 600 008 |
| **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/chennai/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate |
| **Notes** | Full-fledged office with experienced legal team. Supported by Mumbai HO. |

### 6. Bengaluru (Bangalore)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | INDIALAW LLP, No. 7 Chinnaswamy Mudaliar Road, Shivaji Nagar, Bangalore – 560 051 |
| **Phone** | [080-4167-2444](tel:08041672444) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/bengaluru/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate · Family Laws · Labour |
| **Notes** | Located near Bangalore High Court. Handles corporate, commercial, banking and matrimonial disputes. |

### 7. Hyderabad

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | 403, 4th Floor, Sanatana Ecstasy Building, beside Tanishq Show Room, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad – 500 029, Telangana |
| **Phone** | [040-6666-5166](tel:04066665166) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/hyderabad/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Banking · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate |
| **Notes** | Particularly well known for complex banking matters and real estate transactions. |

### 8. Cochin (Kochi)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | Second Floor, Pulikkal Building, K.K. Padmanabhan Road, Ernakulam North – 682 018, Kerala |
| **Phone** | [0484-3583961](tel:04843583961) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/cochin/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate |
| **Notes** | Commercial disputes, property litigation, financial-claim arbitrations and real estate transactions. |

### 9. Noida (NCR)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | No. 16 & 17, Silver Offices, 17th Floor, Wave One, Sector 18, Noida – 201 301 |
| **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/noida/ |
| **Practice focus** | Aviation · Insurance · Mergers & Acquisitions · Corporate |
| **Office head** | **Mr. Dinesh Gupta** (joined August 2025 to lead and expand the corporate practice) |
| **Notes** | Newest office. Sector-focused on highly regulated industries serving NCR-based clients. |

---

## Quick-Dial Phone List

| Office | Phone |
|---|---|
| Mumbai HO (Apeejay) | 022-6924-7400 |
| Mumbai Excelsior | 022-697-40500 |
| Kolkata | +91 33 4813 1001 |
| Bengaluru | 080-4167-2444 |
| Hyderabad | 040-6666-5166 |
| Cochin | 0484-3583961 |
| **General / Marketing line** | **+91 836-9995919** |

Delhi, Chennai and Noida route through the general number.

---

## Social Channels

- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/indialaw
- X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/Indialawmumbai
- Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/indialawllp/
- Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/indialawllp

---