---
title: "Bombay High Court Holds That Employees Cannot Subsequently Challenge Their Promotion After Accepting The Same Without Demur"
date: 2024-07-03
author: "Brian Noronha"
url: https://www.indialaw.in/blog/civil/bombay-high-court-employees-promotion/
---

# Bombay High Court Holds That Employees Cannot Subsequently Challenge Their Promotion After Accepting The Same Without Demur

Posted On - 3 July, 2024 •

By - [Brian Noronha](https://www.indialaw.in/author/brian-noronha/ "Posts by Brian Noronha") and [Amisha Upadhyay](https://www.indialaw.in/author/amisha-upadhyay/ "Posts by Amisha Upadhyay")

[![Bombay High Court](https://www.indialaw.in/wp-content/uploads/BOMBAY-HIGH-COURT-HOLDS-THAT-EMPLOYEES-CANNOT-SUBSEQUENTLY-CHALLENGE-THEIR-PROMOTION-AFTER-ACCEPTING-THE-SAME-WITHOUT-DEMUR.png)](https://www.indialaw.in/wp-content/uploads/BOMBAY-HIGH-COURT-HOLDS-THAT-EMPLOYEES-CANNOT-SUBSEQUENTLY-CHALLENGE-THEIR-PROMOTION-AFTER-ACCEPTING-THE-SAME-WITHOUT-DEMUR.png)

In a recent judgment, passed in the matter of **Shri Shripad Dwarkanath Gupte and Ors. v. Union of India**[[1]](#_ftn1) the Hon’ble Bombay High Court (“**HC**”) elucidated that employees who have accepted promotions based on grades, without any objections are barred from subsequently challenging the same.

This dispute is related to the employees challenging a common judgment and order passed by the Hon’ble Central Administrative Tribunal, Mumbai (Tribunal) (“**CAT**”) wherein the Original Application Nos. 93 of 2017 and 497 of 2017 were dismissed by the CAT vide order dated 21st December 2022.

The Petitioners, in this particular case, were employed as Artisan Staff in various grades i.e. Highly Skilled Grade – II (HSK-II), High Skilled Grade – I (HSK-I), and Chargeman and Foreman in the Technical Supervisory Staff of the Indian Navy employed by the Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard (“**Respondent No.2**”). An Office Memorandum in 2010 (“**said OM**”) was notified by the Ministry of Defence (“**MoD**”) which introduced a new four-grade structure i.e. (i) Skilled, (ii) HSK-II, (iii) HSK-I, and (iv) Master Craftsman as to a three – grade structure previously established. The MoD thereafter, implemented the said OM and issued a revised ratio of different grades in Industrial Trades vide Operative Instruction dated 25th June 2012.

The contention of the Petitioners viz the said OM was that few of the Petitioners due to the said OM and the Operative Instructions were directly promoted to Chargeman, instead of going through the expected promotion of Master Craftsman, and as a consequence, they were denied a pay increment which they would have received otherwise. 

In the instant case, however, the HC upheld the impugned decision of the CAT and opined that out of 25 Petitioners, 13 had been promoted based on grade-wise seniority to Chargeman and Foreman without objecting, reflects their acceptance towards the promotion practices adopted, having consented to the same through their conduct, the doctrine of estoppel would be pertinent. Further, the HC interpreted the said OMs and conceded with the ruling of the CAT that a delay of six years cannot be condoned as it would prejudice and disrupt the seniority which is already in place.

In the humble opinion of the authors, the HC ought to have taken into consideration the practical difficulties being faced by the employees, who are more often than not pressurized into accepting promotions without being fully informed of the consequences of such acceptance.

---

[[1]](#_ftnref1)  Writ Petition No. 2763 of 2023.

Disclaimer - This article is intended for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should seek specific legal counsel in relation to their individual circumstances.

[Download PDF](https://www.indialaw.in/blog/civil/bombay-high-court-employees-promotion//pdf/)

---

# IndiaLaw LLP — Offices & Contact Details

---

## General Contact

| | |
|---|---|
| **Website** | https://www.indialaw.in |
| **Primary email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Primary phone** | +91 836-9995919 |
| **Contact form** | https://www.indialaw.in/connect/ |
| **Careers (separate channel)** | https://www.indialaw.in/careers/ |


---

## All Offices (9 locations across 8 cities)

### 1. Mumbai — Registered Office & Head Office (Apeejay Chambers)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | Apeejay Chambers, Ground Floor, Wallace Street, Fort, Mumbai – 400 001 |
| **Phone** | [022-6924-7400](tel:02269247400) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/mumbai/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Arbitration · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Corporate · Banking · Real Estate · IP |
| **Notes** | The HQ. 5 partners based here. Handles PAN-India litigation, arbitration, corporate, banking, IP and real estate practice. Largest team across all offices. |

### 2. Mumbai — Non-Litigation Office (Excelsior, Fort)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | 4th Floor, New Excelsior Theatre Pvt. Ltd., Amrit Keshav Nayak Marg, Fort, Mumbai – 400 001 |
| **Phone** | [022-697-40500](tel:022-697-40500) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/mumbai/ |
| **Practice focus** | Non-litigation only — consultations, negotiations, transactional work |
| **Notes** | Opened 2024. Litigation and arbitration remain at the Apeejay Chambers head office. |

### 3. Delhi

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | Flat No. 1107 & 1108, Prakashdeep Building, Tolstoy Marg, Connaught Place, New Delhi – 110 001 |
| **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/delhi/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Arbitration · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Corporate · Banking · Real Estate |
| **Notes** | 3 partners based here. Located near the Supreme Court of India, Delhi High Court and other appellate bodies. |

### 4. Kolkata

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | Centre Point Building, Room No. 214, 2nd Floor, Premises No. 21, Hemanta Basu Sarani, Opp. Great Eastern Hotel, P.S. Hare Street, Kolkata – 700 001, West Bengal |
| **Phone** | [+91 33 4813 1001](tel:+913348131001) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/kolkata/ |
| **Practice focus** | Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Commercial & Civil Litigation · Arbitration · Banking Litigation · Real Estate · Labour & Employment · Consumer |
| **Notes** | Advises banks, NBFCs, MSMEs and corporates on transactions and dispute resolution. Works in close coordination with the Mumbai HO. |

### 5. Chennai

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | GF-A, 19 Casa Major Road, Egmore, Chennai – 600 008 |
| **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/chennai/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate |
| **Notes** | Full-fledged office with experienced legal team. Supported by Mumbai HO. |

### 6. Bengaluru (Bangalore)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | INDIALAW LLP, No. 7 Chinnaswamy Mudaliar Road, Shivaji Nagar, Bangalore – 560 051 |
| **Phone** | [080-4167-2444](tel:08041672444) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/bengaluru/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate · Family Laws · Labour |
| **Notes** | Located near Bangalore High Court. Handles corporate, commercial, banking and matrimonial disputes. |

### 7. Hyderabad

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | 403, 4th Floor, Sanatana Ecstasy Building, beside Tanishq Show Room, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad – 500 029, Telangana |
| **Phone** | [040-6666-5166](tel:04066665166) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/hyderabad/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Banking · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate |
| **Notes** | Particularly well known for complex banking matters and real estate transactions. |

### 8. Cochin (Kochi)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | Second Floor, Pulikkal Building, K.K. Padmanabhan Road, Ernakulam North – 682 018, Kerala |
| **Phone** | [0484-3583961](tel:04843583961) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/cochin/ |
| **Practice focus** | Litigation · Insolvency & Bankruptcy · Real Estate |
| **Notes** | Commercial disputes, property litigation, financial-claim arbitrations and real estate transactions. |

### 9. Noida (NCR)

| | |
|---|---|
| **Address** | No. 16 & 17, Silver Offices, 17th Floor, Wave One, Sector 18, Noida – 201 301 |
| **Phone** | (general line: +91 836-9995919) |
| **Email** | contact@indialaw.in |
| **Page** | https://www.indialaw.in/noida/ |
| **Practice focus** | Aviation · Insurance · Mergers & Acquisitions · Corporate |
| **Office head** | **Mr. Dinesh Gupta** (joined August 2025 to lead and expand the corporate practice) |
| **Notes** | Newest office. Sector-focused on highly regulated industries serving NCR-based clients. |

---

## Quick-Dial Phone List

| Office | Phone |
|---|---|
| Mumbai HO (Apeejay) | 022-6924-7400 |
| Mumbai Excelsior | 022-697-40500 |
| Kolkata | +91 33 4813 1001 |
| Bengaluru | 080-4167-2444 |
| Hyderabad | 040-6666-5166 |
| Cochin | 0484-3583961 |
| **General / Marketing line** | **+91 836-9995919** |

Delhi, Chennai and Noida route through the general number.

---

## Social Channels

- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/indialaw
- X / Twitter: https://twitter.com/Indialawmumbai
- Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/indialawllp/
- Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/indialawllp

---